I think we all found out that 18AA is more competitive than 18A. The pitching is overall better, the hitting is overall better and we certainly held our own to finish as well as we did the first time out.
Compare seasons:
Spring 2011 (18A): Record 8-2 regular season, 1-1 post season
Hits: Scrubs 191 Opponents 105
Run production: Scrubs 185 Opponents 65
Pitching: Matty 65-2/3 of 90 innings, Rob 16-2/3 of 90 innings (Matty literally carried the mound on his back)
Summer 2011 (18AA): Record 5-5 regular season, did not make post-season
Hits: Scrubs 121 Opponents 107
Run production: Scrubs 82 Opponents 77
Pitching (after adding 3 new, quality pitchers) Andrew 35-1/3 innings, Jesse 19-1/3 innings, Kirby 16-1/3 innings, Matty 15 innings. We had DEPTH in the bullpen for the first time ever, and I think that is how we fared as well as we did.
What you have to decide in the next few days is: (1) With only two of the four arms from the Summer season, plus Rob, and probably with Jesse out of action some of the time because when the USMC wants you on Saturday morning, you don't go play baseball instead, do we have enough guns to stay in AA without embarrassing ourselves? (2) Are we fairly confident that we've seen enough AA pitching by now to be able to do an adequate job at the plate? We've lit AA pitchers up a few times. They've frozen us in our tracks a few times, too. The freeze-outs never happened in single A. Do we have it figured out now? (3) We know that no matter how effective our pitchers are, plenty of balls are going to be put in play. Can we overcome our occasional "ball allergy" enough to not let anyone drop 6 or 8 runs on us in an inning? That "inning from hell" is always the turning point.
If all or most of the answers are "yes" the Scrubs may just be a double-A team. Otherwise, single-A is going to be more fun, more successful, and as someone upstream in this thread said, go back to 18A and get back to AA the right way, by winning a championship. Although beating some weak-ass team by 15 runs isn't as much fun as beating a good team by 1 or 2 runs.
The 18AA mix may change for the fall season because the Yankees and possibly the Spikes will move up. Somebody from single A will roll in and be the rookies we were 10 weeks ago. Whoever they are, we will know them and have beaten them when we were in 18A.
I'm not voting, this is your team and your decision. I'm also not crusading for it to go one way or the other, just raising some points as somebody who has watched nearly every pitch, every at-bat, every infield and outfield play for soon to be four years. Either way, it's not forever, it's only for 10 games and then you can reconsider during the dead zone before the next spring season. And either way, good luck and let's go kick some of that ass in the fall!


