There’s an old saying: “Put a spoonful of wine into a barrel of sewage and you have a barrel of sewage. Put a spoonful of sewage into a barrel of wine and you have a barrel of sewage.”
In the past two weeks, I’ve been contacted twice by one of our team’s top-shelf players, pointing out that several of his statistics were wrong. That major items were missing. In checking it out, I’ve found that he was absolutely right both times. A missing hit, a missing RBI. Both were in the book, neither made it to the on-line stats. What is worrisome is that there are very likely other similar omissions. A lot of good stats. A few bad ones. The spoonful of sewage in the barrel of wine.
So what does this mean for the Scrubs? I’ve worked in the broadcasting industry my entire adult life. Broadcasting lives and dies by statistics. Audience ratings, market research, music testing, focus groups and the like. You learn during your rookie year that it’s better to have no statistics than bad ones. Bad stats lead to bad decisions. Having no statistics at least gives you a fighting chance to guess right. It’s evident to me that we have bad statistics. There are mistakes; we just don’t know how many or where they are. I no longer trust our stats, and I’m sure that player who’s numbers have been wrong two weeks running doesn’t either.
I know, it’s weekend rec ball. Nobody is going to be sent down to the single A franchise in Visalia over his stats. Still, if they are not trustworthy, there is very little point in spending the 60 to 90 minutes after each game preparing them, building them into the web site, finding out about the errors, then preparing them and updating the web again and hoping nobody else e-mails another mistake. I’m doing this baseball stuff for exactly the same reason you all are. You play ball because it’s fun. I do what I do because I’m not a player but love the game, and the whole package of what I do is my Sunday fun. Turning out a product that is of very limited usefulness is not fun.
For now, I have taken the stats and leader board off-line. Both are known to be incorrect. I am going to consider for a bit whether to fix them and put them back on-line. If I conclude that it's pointless to produce something that everyone considers suspect, I will leave them off-line, give Scott hard copies of the season so far (mistakes and all) and leave it up to him what, if anything, to do about statistics.
Either way, I will still do your book, rake the infield and maintain the website at least through the end of the season. But evidence so far indicates that I am incapable of getting these stats done properly. And that’s the only way I’ll do them.
-Doug Herman
